Cardiff vs Swansea: Three Battles That Will Decide The South Wales Derby


Matches between Cardiff and Swansea are so often decided by the smallest margins.

Whether a moment of brilliance or catastrophic error, often a south Wales derby can be decided on an individual willing to stamp their name on a tight, cagey match.

With that in mind, here are three key battles that might just decide the 119th derby between Swansea and Cardiff on Saturday:

Alex Robertson vs Matt Grimes

The battle of the midfield will be a fierce one at the Cardiff City Stadium, with Swansea expected to dominate possession, despite being the visitors.

This midfield clash pits Cardiff’s creative heartbeat against Swansea’s captain and anchor. Robertson’s endeavour and attacking instincts will test Grimes’ ability to shield his defence while dictating Swansea’s tempo. The player who asserts control in the middle of the park could set the tone for their team.

25.08.24 - Swansea City v Cardiff City, Sky Bet Championship - Alex Robertson of Cardiff City
25.08.24 – Swansea City v Cardiff City, Sky Bet Championship – Alex Robertson of Cardiff City.

The young midfielder, on loan from Manchester City, possesses excellent technical skills and vision. Robertson’s agility and ability to operate between the lines make him a creative force who can unlock a defence with precise passes. However, his relative inexperience in high-stakes matches like the South Wales derby may see him struggle under intense pressure, particularly against a seasoned campaigner like Grimes.

Grimes is the engine of Swansea’s midfield, combining defensive solidity with exceptional passing range. His calmness on the ball and ability to dictate play are essential for Swansea’s rhythm. Where Robertson can get at the Swans’ captain is that Grimes can sometimes leave gaps when venturing forward, and a quick, energetic midfielder like Robertson could exploit these spaces.

25.08.24 - Swansea City v Cardiff City, South Wales Derby - SkyBet Championship - Matt Grimes of Swansea City
25.08.24 – Swansea City v Cardiff City, South Wales Derby – SkyBet Championship – Matt Grimes of Swansea City

Callum Robinson vs Ben Cabango

Robinson’s pace and movement against Cabango’s strength and defensive acumen promises to be a fascinating duel. Robinson will aim to exploit any gaps in Swansea’s defence, while Cabango will look to dominate aerially and thwart Cardiff’s forward thrusts. A moment of brilliance from either could be decisive.

With Cabango facing a race to be fit for the match, Robinson can potentially exploit any rustiness felt by the Swansea man.

Robinson’s pace, clever movement, and ability to find space make him a dangerous forward. He’s clinical in one-on-one situations and thrives when given room to exploit. Yet his effectiveness wanes when isolated or crowded out by defenders, and he can be prone to frustration if chances are limited.

Cabango is a commanding presence in defence, excelling in aerial duels and physical battles. He’s also composed in possession, helping Swansea build from the back. While solid defensively, he can struggle against quicker forwards, like Robinson, in transition and is sometimes vulnerable to clever off-the-ball movement.

25.08.24 - Swansea City v Cardiff City, South Wales Derby - SkyBet Championship - Ben Cabango of Swansea City is challenged by Callum Robinson of Cardiff City
25.08.24 – Swansea City v Cardiff City, South Wales Derby – SkyBet Championship – Ben Cabango of Swansea City is challenged by Callum Robinson of Cardiff City

Perry Ng vs Liam Cullen

Cardiff’s defensive stalwart Perry Ng will have his hands full containing the lively Liam Cullen, who has a knack for finding space in the box and scoring in derby matches. Ng’s positioning and composure will be tested by Cullen’s sharp movement and clinical finishing.

Ng is a versatile defender known for his excellent reading of the game and ability to time tackles well. His leadership in the backline ensures Cardiff remains organized but he can sometimes be caught out by quick combinations or pacey attackers exploiting wide areas.

For Swansea, Cullen is a natural finisher who thrives in tight spaces. His sharp movement in and around the box makes him a constant threat, particularly against slower defenders. He can be less effective when forced to play with his back to goal and can struggle in physical duels against robust defenders.

If Ng gets physical with Cullen, he may be able to reduce his effectiveness and Swansea’s overall attacking patterns.

16.03.24 - Swansea City v Cardiff City - Sky Bet Championship - Perry Ng of Cardiff Cityis fouled by Liam Cullen of Swansea City.
16.03.24 – Swansea City v Cardiff City – Sky Bet Championship – Perry Ng of Cardiff Cityis fouled by Liam Cullen of Swansea City.

If you want to read more pieces from Sportin Wales, why not read to our monthly magazine here or subscribe to the magazine and newsletter at https://sportin.wales/subscribe/.

Our podcast is back for the new season and our co-founder Alex Cuthbert is in charge! You can find all the episodes here or the video versions on our YouTube channel.

You can also keep track of our pieces and videos on our socials at @Sportin_Wales on X or Sportin Wales on Instagram and Facebook.